Winter
I had known her for a while. She had dimples on both cheeks, though the one on the right cheek sunk deeper than the other. I wasn't in love with her. I only noticed because I liked to look at the way she laughed. I wasn't in love with her. But she would smile wide once, straighten her lips and laugh aloud till there were tears in her eyes. I wasn't in love with her. But we didn't have a car so I insisted she put her right hand in my left pocket. I wasn't really in love with her. But she woke up to wildly graphic nightmares and we disabled the fire alarm and smoked cigarettes while she described them to me.
I don't think I loved her.
But it was colder than usual that year and New York was a giant glowing icicle and we walked gingerly on every avenue, going into shops that smelled like candy and marijuana.
I was in business school. Abigail, let us call her Abigail, because her name isn't really Abigail, scoffed when I told her that. She scoffed again when we were at the foot of the lighthouse in Montauk, watching the cold sea trying to crack open stoic, brown rocks.
"This place, doesn't it make you want to melt into it? To be one of the maroon pebbles, just an inch under the water. And you still want to wear a suit and work from behind a glass window. "
I was irritated.
"It isn't the worst thing in the world, making some money. Maybe I will make enough money to buy a house in the Hamptons"
"Well I could never do it. The best lines I write are on kitchen towels when I am hungover"
Abigail was a poet, did I tell you Abigail was a poet? I mean she fancied herself a poet. She was all the idealistic, whimsical, impulsive dreamy crap that I envied.
"Abigail, it's a fine evening and we are twenty three. But you don't really know what you want, do you?"
"Oh, but I do. Don't you?"
I think I blushed, even in the cold air. I felt viciously uncomfortable.
"I mean, nobody has got it all figured out. This was a change. And I like New York. I like you."
She rolled her eyes. "I can't picture you in a suit. Maybe an ill-fitted suit."
I clenched my fists. I couldn't be in love with her. I was so wildly jealous of how every hair on her body had found freedom and decided to stay in it.
We stood in silence, till the sea engulfed the sun and the cold seeped into our hearts.
New year's eve. We went ice skating in Bryant park. When she fell on her elbow we decided to sit down by the stone fountain. They had turned off the water. There were children all around, whining and blowing their noses. An impeccably dressed gentleman asked if I could take a picture of him with his disgruntled date.
"Do you go to college here?"
"I do, sir, Columbia."
I could feel Abigail fidgeting beside me. She disliked new people.
"I had a cousin there. He dropped out though. Went on to become a poet."
His date snorted loudly.
"He wrote those poems that don't rhyme. A real hippie."
I could not stop myself from being utterly petty.
"Yeah, do you know anyone who is a poet these days? Like, is that a real job, even?"
I thought Abigail would roll her eyes and preach to me later, loudly and drunkenly about the wastefulness of my halfhearted pursuits, and how I was just malicious of her freedom. I thought Abigail would stomp the ice and I would catch her as she slipped and sigh as I listened to her rant. But she didn't do anything. I heard her crying in the shower. When she came out I asked her if she would watch the Amy Winehouse documentary. We didn't really talk that night.
The evening before she left, we had cherry wine sitting beside the heater, and she gave me a blue tie with a handwritten note. I wasn't in love with her. But we effortlessly belonged in movie screens. I couldn't be in love with her. I attributed it to the snow and the city and youth.
**
Summer
My wife and I bickered all the way to the hospital. The air conditioner was out of order and she hated rolling down the windows. It upset her hair. It also upset her that we did not spend much time together. I loved her sometimes, when it wasn't so hot in New York.
We lived in a sleepy hamlet now, where families of deer crowded behind the barbed fence. I sat outside on summer nights and looked at their delicate gait. Sometimes when we were driving, we would find them at deer crossings, staring at the two of us, calling us out on our quiet insecurities. My beautiful angry wife and I.
She told me she hated my guts and my headphones and the coffee rings I left everywhere. She told me everyday when I did not have the headphones on.
I did not mind. I wrote about it. My beautiful angry wife. It was comic sometimes, tragic sometimes, always familiar. My readers sympathized. One even wrote me a heartfelt letter about how I should've stayed with Abigail. It was amusing.
I stopped the car and played with a tie discarded on the dashboard. Blue silk. My wife gathered her things. I loved her sometimes, in pieces.
"You really should get your life together. I need you to meet me in the middle. I can't fix things for both of us. This isn't a real job", began my wife, Abigail, the nurse.
"You're just jealous because I know what I am doing."
I turned up the music as I watched her stomp away.